DRAM Price-Fixing Allegations: Manufacturers' Motion to Dismiss Fails
The legal battle over alleged price-fixing in the DRAM market has taken a significant turn. A US federal judge has denied a joint motion filed by the industry's three largest players—Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron—to dismiss a class-action lawsuit. The decision means the litigation, which accuses the manufacturers of orchestrating supply shortages to artificially drive up prices, will proceed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.
The lawsuit, originally filed in June 2026, was brought by 17 plaintiffs, including individuals and smaller companies across five US states. The core of the complaint is an accusation of market manipulation: the plaintiffs allege that the dominant manufacturers deliberately restricted the supply of conventional DRAM to inflate market prices. Together, Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron control more than 90% of the global DRAM market, giving them significant influence over global pricing structures.
Evidence of Coordinated Supply Reduction
The plaintiffs point to several synchronized business decisions as circumstantial evidence of a coordinated effort to tighten supply. Key points cited in the complaint include production cuts implemented between October 2022 and April 2023, a strategic shift of manufacturing capacity toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) for AI accelerators, and the near-simultaneous withdrawal from DDR4 production. Furthermore, the plaintiffs argue that manufacturers failed to expand capacity despite significantly higher memory prices, suggesting a managed scarcity rather than a natural market response.
According to the legal filings, prices for conventional DRAM reportedly surged by a total of 697% within an 18-month period. While the manufacturers attribute these price hikes to the massive surge in demand from AI data centers, the plaintiffs contend that the price escalation is not solely a result of market demand, but rather a consequence of coordinated supply constraints.
The Defense: Economic Necessity vs. Collusion
Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron have vehemently denied the allegations. Their defense rests on the argument that their business decisions were made independently and were driven by legitimate economic considerations. They maintain that in a market dominated by a few major players, similar reactions to shifting demand conditions are common and do not imply collusion. Additionally, the companies characterized the class action as a repeat of a previous 2018 litigation that was dismissed in 2022.
However, Judge Noël Wise did not find the manufacturers' arguments sufficient to halt the proceedings. The court ruled that the combination of production cuts, the pivot to HBM manufacturing, and the exit from older memory standards provides enough grounds to investigate potential anti-competitive agreements. While the court's decision allows the investigation to move forward, the actual existence of a coordinated conspiracy remains to be proven in court.